About a year before my dad passed away, he and I were at the store about to enter the store to do some grocery shopping when comes along a lady stooped at 90 degree angle pushing a buggy full of groceries. My heart immediately sank at this site. This lady apparently had been shopping all alone. I wonder how it was possible to live like this (bringing back memories of some of my dystonic patients further gripping my heart). Sensing my anguish, before I could say or do anything being completely paralyzed at the site of this phenomenal woman who ventured all alone despite the pain she must be have likely been enduring, my father quietly stated- “I so hate that you are sick.”
I turned and looked at him with intrigue in my eyes. “But dad that poor woman…” as I trailed off he said: “I know you are a great doctor and if you were working I bet you could help her get better.”
A lump formed in my throat thinking about this person and so many more that could use my skills as a doctor, after all I was nowhere near as disabled as this person in front of us.
Before I could get to her someone came and help her load her truck and I had to watch and see how she was going to drive. Sure enough as I though, when she climbed unto the vehicle and set down she was able to straighten up.
My dad was amazed at this. I explained to him this was a form of dystonia (abnormal sustained involuntary contraction of the muscles) called Camptocormia (a.k.a bent spine). This is a dystonic posturing linked to atrophy of the paraspinal muscles. This is posturing is known as one of the extreme postures impairments linked or associated with Parkinson’s disease (PD). Camptocormia in Parkinson’s is defined as extreme anteroflexion of the trunk which abates with recumbent position or standing up against a wall or hard surface. Thus this lady possibly had PD –dystonia at the very least. PD patients who have this tend to have early involvement of axial muscles and long duration of illness as well as tend be older of male gender with history of spondyloarthric spine increasing risk of developing camptocormia. This particular dystonia does not respond to levodopa or have very minimal response. Interestingly, the Pet scans looking at dopamine transporters of PD patients with and without Camptocormia are identical.
Although dad knew little of neurology or dystonia he had a good 6th sense and was correct in assuming this woman’s condition was in my area of expertise. I frequently think of both that lady who I have not seen again and my dad who is now gone to be with the Lord. Yet, the resolve to understand the connection between the two movement disorders in an attempt to find relief to so many people in need has only strengthen with time.
There are two other dystonic syndromes involving the AXIAL muscles commonly seen by MDS that are frequently related to parkinsonian patients:
- Head drop (anterocollis- cervical dystonia)
- Pisa Syndrome- a condition in which there is sustained involuntary flexion of the body and head to one side and slight rotation of the trunk when sitting and standing. This gives the appearance of leaning tower of Pisa – hence the name! This condition also commonly seen in schizophrenia.
These two are typically related to Multisystem atrophy (MSA)! However, Pisa syndrome can be seen infrequently in PD as well. Those that have this syndrome tend to have lower body mass index; higher disability due to longer duration of disease and more advanced disease. Subsequently, PD patients with Pisa syndrome had poorer quality of life partly due to increased falling. Severe osteoporosis and arthrosis were significantly part of the life of these patients as well. Although, anterocollis is a sin-qua- non of MSA in its early presentation but when it occurs in the late stages of PD it is invariably due to medication effect (wearing off).
Despite the fact that dystonia is the third most common movement disorder after essential tremors (ET) and PD is still not well recognized or understood; even though there have been many advances in the last several decades identifying specific genes causing dystonic syndromes.
One of the main problems in dealing with dystonia from a medical point of view is that it is both a symptom as well as a diagnosis of primary neurological disease. This notion has always intrigued me particularly after I developed YOPD and my initial symptoms as it is common in the majority of YOPD to commence with some sort of focal dystonia. Despite the fact that I have been trying for a number of years to get the Parkinson’s foundations to work side by side the dystonia foundation to focus on the common path ways. After a decade, I am happy to report progress by a final acknowledgement of dystonia as a presenting symptoms of PD by the MJfox foundation. Further, they are beginning to recognize a pattern of presentation which is essential in the diagnostic armamentarium of every physician (who depend on pattern recognition) but also for the PD community to be aware of the possible initial symptoms.
Keeping above in mind we also have to remember that dystonia itself is not a common /classic presenting symptom of PD. However, when it is the presenting symptoms it’s in YOPD. In YOPD, dystonia is more commonly isolated in the lower limb as it was my presenting symptom. As a symptom in general isolated lower limb dystonia is very rare in adults. This dystonia is also referred as kinesigenic foot dystonia this is because this type of dystonia is brought on by exercise and/ or movement of the foot- typically causing toes to curl involuntarily and sometimes exaggerated hyperflexion of foot causing much pain and discomfort.
Common trigger is putting on shoes for women particularly if attempting to put on high heels as they cause us to arch our foot even further.
Treatments: Vary depending on cause
As with any illness – the key to successful treatment is first deciding its cause- whether the dystonia in any individual is a symptom of an underlying neurological disease or a disease itself such as primary dystonia or Dopa- responsive -dystonia (DRD)?
Once you have ascertained that these syndromes are part of Parkinson’s or Parkinson’s plus disorders then we must consider their treatment.
- Anterocollis– Commonly causes neck pain and cervical radiculopathy. Botox works wonders; adjusting PD meds; therapy, cervical collar & DBS. Must recognize and treat early before cervical damage can occur and or cause fracture of c-spine!
- Pisa syndrome– Commonly causes back pain. Discontinue using antipsychotic drugs and usage of amantadine and other anti-cholinergics; no good treatment for those caused by neuroleptics.
- Camptocormia- Commonly causes back pain and lumbar/thoracic radiculopathy. Since levodopa has little or no effect we must consider alternative treatments. These include: withdrawal of causative drugs like antipsychotics or neuroleptic drugs such as Haldol; orthotic aids; Physical therapy; steroid injections; Botox injections which have proven of great value in many patients with this type of dystonia- would be my first choice after excluding triggering causes/medical causes; muscle relaxants – baclofen, dantrolene, etc.; tetrabenazine; amantadine; and surgical intervention -such as DBS- deep brain stimulation- subthalamic
- Lower limb dystonia– start dopamine agonists; levodopa; physical therapy; foot orthotics; Botox; muscle relaxants; DBS when necessary.
In summary having one of the first 3 syndromes in the presence of PD is a sign of disabling advanced disease leading to higher comorbidities which in turn can lead to spine fractures of neck and back requiring surgery if not properly treated and managed early in its presentation. The latter two frequently result in severe falls due to loss of balance and “veering” of gait. However, presence of lower limb dystonia in a young adult could signify the onset of Parkinson’s disease. Thus, need to follow up with a neurologist/ MDS for all these types of dystonia for a better prognosis and quality of life.
Pisa syndrome in Parkinson disease
Dolhun, R. The Michael J. Fox foundation for Parkinson’s Research. (September 2015) :”Dystonia and Parkinson’s Disease.” Practical Neurology. 14(7):43-46.
10 thoughts on “Rare Dystonia Syndromes and Parkinson’s Disease: By Dr. De Leon”
The Dystonia Society N/East England GB. branch have found this information very interesting
This was so interesting, the first time I’m 2 years I have heard of anyone else having lower limb dystonia as predominant problem of PD. My neurologist seems to think I am faking it, and that as I have very little tremor the Parkinson’s is therefor under control. I would love to know more of your research is this area. My left leg twists , curls, cramps, feels like there is a dagger in the calf muscle and I have a self inflicted sprained ankle. Other times I am fine! But very little energy. I was a 747 captain with British Airways, now I just try and cope with day to day life. But I still have a great joy of life., only rarely feel depressed. I have just ordered your Diva book. I am in the uk but have a son training to be a helicopter pilot in Titusville.
I am so very sorry to hear that you too are having this problem…as I mentioned lower limb dystonia is not common in adults and when it is present it is a sign that most likely dealing with Parkinson’s. however, any good neurologist will need to rule out other causes first! I too presented this way.. it was so very painful and I too sprained my ankle and fell a lot. PD meds will stop this if due to PD – I have found Azilect to work great for the pain of PD. So proud of your work…I have had patients who were also pilots and could no longer fly and after DBS – deep brain stimulation have been back to work – something to think about if meds are interfering with flying. you know PD is usually not hereditary so your son should not necessarily have this. you may like this link as well which you can share with your neurologist too. best of luck. you can reach me also at firstname.lastname@example.org
Thank you for you response it is so good to,know it is not just me! And I have forwarded your article to my neurologist. I can’t imagine I will ever fly professionally again, I am too tired and feel too easily stressed nowadays and I am enjoying the freedom of retirement. but anything to relieve the pain and help,with walking would be so good. I will ask to try Azilect. Do you have much tremor, I have never really presented with tremor but now do notice it when meds wear off. More of an internal tremor than my hands. Best wishes and thank you – kate.
I too did not have much tremor and still very little..I feel shaky inside as well funny because my tremor is always been most pronounced in my big toe- good luck! Best wishes to you too and keep me posted on your progress.
How does one tell the difference if leg cramps is caused by dystopia or Parkinson’s .
hi mary.. did you see my article on leg and toe cramps?
if you still have questions let me know.. God bless.
Thank you again Dr De Leon for explaining my PD symptoms. I also commented in regards to nasal symptoms.
My spine has lordosis in the lumbar region and kyphosis in the thoracic region. My head is bent forward and I am usually looking down. It is painful to straighten up when I walk. My lower back aches. I cannot measure my height by putting my back against a wall with my butt, upper back and head touching the wall. I am a couple inches shorter than I used to be. An X-ray showed that I have one wedge shaped thoracic vertebrae. My primary care physician said it must be from a compression fracture. Bone density studies show I have osteopenia.
I also have kinesigenic foot dystonia. During “off” times the toes on my right foot curl under. It is painful to straighten up my toes.
It seems that PD symptoms of difficult swallowing, E.D. and spinal problems occurred about 20 years before tremors started and PD was diagnosed.
Thank you again for explaining it all to me.
Osteoporosis is higher in pd patients both from pd and also from meds. Sorry you are hurting. Talk to doctor about possibly increasing pd doses to help the symptoms plus congestion and get sleep study to rule out apnea as cause of early headaches. And maybe even check vitamin D which tends to be low in pd patients and increase osteoporosis/ penia ..best of luck …happy holidays again